The final vote on equal marriage.  Really. Mean it this time.

 

 

 

 

What Canadians think about gay marriage (Video by Steven Townsend)

 

 

Affect change: The increased influence of attitudinal factors on Canadians' support for legal same-sex marriage (By Mark Warren Lehman, 2006)

 

 



Web

 

Send this page to a friend!

 

Legal News - The final vote. Really. Mean it this time.

December 7, 2006

The final vote. Really. Mean it this time.
Getting on with married life, thank you very much

By Kevin Bourassa and Joe Varnell

The worst in politics

"I think all Canadians should worry about a political party that holds neither human rights nor the courts in the highest esteem. How can we possibly be comfortable with a government that follows the dictates of a narrow subset of our population - the religious right - over the vast majority of Canadians? What other demands will Stephen Harper and his Conservatives have to satisfy to keep the support of this small but determined group?"
Buzz Hargrove, President
Canadian Auto Workers
CNW, Dec. 7, 2006

As expected, the motion against same-sex marriage, put forward by Stephen Harper's Conservatives, failed in Parliament today. The debate, which began yesterday afternoon and went late into the night ended today with a vote of 123 for the motion and 175 MPs against (including 6 Conservative cabinet members).

The number of Conservatives voting in favour of gay marriage increased from three last year to thirteen today. Meanwhile, the number of Liberals voting against equal marriage dropped from thirty-two last year to thirteen today.

Even Liberal Joe Comuzzi who quit Paul Martin's cabinet last year, in order to vote against gay marriage last year, voted against Harper's motion today.

For and Against Harper's motion :
Conservatives: 110-13
Liberals: 13-85
NDP: 0-30
Bloc Quebecois: 0-47

How MPs voted A list of how MPs voted on the Conservative motion to introduce legislation ending equal marriage, in alphabetical order:

For motion (123): Abbott, Ablonczy, Albrecht, Allen, Allison, Ambrose, Anders, Anderson, Batters, Benoit, Bernier, Bezan, Blackburn, Blaney, Bonin, Boucher, Breitkreuz, Brown (Barrie), Brown (Leeds-Grenville), Bruinooge, Byrne, Calkins, Cannan (Kelowna-Lake Country), Carrie, Casson, Clement, Cullen (Etobicoke North), Cummins, Davidson, Day, Del Mastro, Devolin, Doyle, Dykstra, Epp, Fast, Finley, Fitzpatrick, Flaherty, Fletcher, Gallant, Goldring, Goodyear, Gourde, Grewal, Guergis, Hanger, Harper, Harris, Harvey, Hawn, Hearn, Hiebert, Hill, Hinton, Jaffer, Jean, Kamp (Pitt Meadows-Maple Ridge-Mission), Karygiannis, Kenney (Calgary Southeast), Khan, Komarnicki, Kramp (Prince Edward-Hastings), Lake, Lauzon, Lee, Lemieux, Lukiwski, Lunn, Lunney, MacKenzie, Malhi, Mark, Mayes, McKay (Scarborough-Guildwood), McTeague, Menzies, Merrifield, Miller, Mills, Moore (Fundy Royal), Nicholson, Norlock, Obhrai, O'Connor, Oda, Pallister, Petit, Poilievre, Preston, Rajotte, Reid, Ritz, Scarpaleggia, Scheer, Schellenberger, Shipley, Skelton, Smith, Solberg, Sorenson, Stanton, Steckle, Storseth, Strahl, Sweet, Thompson (New Brunswick Southwest), Thompson (Wild Rose), Tilson, Toews, Tonks, Trost, Tweed, Van Kesteren, Van Loan, Vellacott, Wallace, Wappel, Warawa, Warkentin, Watson, Williams, Yelich.

Against motion (175): Alghabra, Andre, Angus, Asselin, Atamanenko, Bachand, Bagnell, Bains, Baird, Barbot, Beaumier, Belanger, Bell (North Vancouver), Bell (Vancouver Island North), Bellavance, Bennett, Bevilacqua, Bevington, Bigras, Black, Blaikie, Blais, Bonsant, Boshcoff, Bouchard, Bourgeois, Brison, Brown (Oakville), Brunelle, Cannon (Pontiac), Carrier, Casey, Chamberlain, Chan, Charlton, Chong, Chow, Christopherson, Coderre, Comartin, Comuzzi, Cotler, Crete, Crowder, Cullen (Skeena-Bulkley Valley), Cuzner, D'Amours, Davies, DeBellefeuille, Demers, Deschamps, Dewar, Dhaliwal, Dhalla, Dion, Dosanjh, Dryden, Duceppe, Easter, Emerson, Eyking, Faille, Freeman, Fry, Gagnon, Gaudet, Gauthier, Godfrey, Godin, Goodale, Graham, Guarnieri, Guay, Guimond, Holland, Hubbard, Ignatieff, Jennings, Julian, Kadis, Karetak-Lindell, Keddy (South Shore-St. Margaret's), Keeper, Kotto, Laforest, Laframboise, Lalonde, Lapierre, Lavallee, Layton, LeBlanc, Lemay, Lessard, Levesque, Lussier, MacAulay, MacKay (Central Nova), Malo, Maloney, Manning, Marleau, Marston, Martin (Esquimalt-Juan de Fuca), Martin (LaSalle-Emard), Martin (Sault Ste. Marie), Martin (Winnipeg Centre), Masse, Mathyssen, Matthews, McCallum, McDonough, McGuinty, McGuire, Menard (Hochelaga), Menard (Marc-Aurele-Fortin), Merasty, Minna, Moore (Port Moody-WestwooduPort Coquitlam), Mourani, Murphy (Charlottetown), Murphy (Moncton-Riverview-Dieppe), Nadeau, Nash, Neville, Ouellet, Owen, Pacetti, Paquette, Paradis, Patry, Pearson, Perron, Peterson, Picard, Plamondon, Prentice, Priddy, Proulx, Ratansi, Redman, Regan, Richardson, Robillard, Rodriguez, Rota, Roy, Russell, Savage, Savoie, Scott, Sgro, Siksay, Silva, Simard, Simms, St. Amand, St. Denis, St-Cyr, St-Hilaire, Stoffer, Stronach, Szabo, Telegdi, Temelkovski, Thibault (West Nova), Turner, Valley, Verner, Vincent, Volpe, Wasylycia-Leis, Wilfert, Wilson, Wrzesnewskyj, Zed.

Although the Toronto Star called this motion "the last major threat to same-sex marriage rights in Canada", it was a hollow threat from the beginning, all bluff when accompanied by the promise to honour Charter rights.

During last night's debate, CanWest news reported today, "the Commons was virtually empty, with about 20 of 308 members showing up."

The motion served no purpose other than to appease religious extremists promoting faith-based bigotry through Harper's ideological agenda.

"Demonstrating the worst in politics - and why so many people are so cynical - Stephen Harper and his Conservatives went ahead with a motion on same-sex marriage that they knew would fail - and even if it passed, knew would never succeed on the legal road ahead," said Buzz Hargrove, President of the Canadian Auto Workers (CNW, Dec. 7, 2006). "But they decided that the human rights of gays and lesbians were worth less than their own political need to appease their religious right backers, who demanded the vote."

Religious extremists won't be retreating to their own homes and churches anytime soon. But they have lost a champion for their cause in Stephen Harper, who insists that the issue of marriage equality is settled for the Conservative party - at least until the party elects another leader or holds another policy convention.

Canadian Press reports today:

Prime Minister Stephen Harper said he heard the message and will respect it. "We made a promise to have a free vote on this issue, we kept that promise, and obviously the vote was decisive and obviously we'll accept the democratic result of the people's representatives," Harper said. "I don't see reopening this question in the future."

Transport Minister Lawrence Cannon told the Toronto Star today, “The file is finished. We’re turning the page.”

Now, we have some Christmas decorating to do around the house before the in-laws come over (we like that phrase, "in-laws"). The season marks the 6th anniversary of the reading of our banns, prior to our marriage and subsequent court challenge.

"It was the beginning of a movement that has so very far to go," Toronto Sun columnist Steve Simmons wrote of our marriage. "It was the beginning of the stripping away of another accepted wrong."

And so it continues, here at home, and around the world.


Please join us in a letter writing campaign to demand our rights from politicians - Click here to learn more


Join us as we legalize same-sex marriage.  Subscribe to our free newsletter

Please help us pay for our advocacy expenses in support of same-sex marriage.
MailLink to our media coverage of related issues.